Regime change and the ‘Arab spring’

The Arab spring has been marked by the revolutionary downfall and removal of autocratic leaders in Tunisia (President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali), Egypt (President Hosni Mubarrak), and Libya (President Momar Gaddafi). Major protests, strikes, and demonstrations have occurred throughout the region, destabilizing regimes in Syria and Yemen. Stirrings of popular unrest during the 'Arab spring' have renewed debate about the regimes most likely to replace traditional autocracies in the region. These events have encouraged many commentators to hope that the Middle East and North Africa is experiencing the gradual transition from autocracy to secular democracies, where moderate Islamic parties, new constitutions, and elected governments gradually expand human rights, including religious freedoms, pluralism, and tolerance of diverse faiths. Preliminary results from the October elections in Tunisia suggest victory for the moderate Islamic party Ennahda. Yet it remains unclear whether the outcome will be similar for moderate forces in Egypt and Libya. Contemporary events remain in continuous flux, the final outcome of these developments are far from settled, and other commentators fear that the instability caused by the popular uprisings will allow openings for conservative and more extremist religious forces to come to power, enforcing stricter interpretation of Islamic law.

Do Muslim publics want secular democracies, characterized by religious pluralism, separation of religious and government authorities, tolerance of diverse religious beliefs and practices, moderate parties, and constitutions where no single type of faith is privileged, following the Turkish model? Or do they prefer regimes where constitutions reflect Islamic principles, spiritual authorities predominate in politics, conservative Islamic parties prevail, and religious courts enforce Sharia law, reflecting the Iranian model? Or, alternatively, do many Muslim publics fall somewhere between these two poles?

Many factors will probably determine the final type of constitutional settlements and the regimes which develop in the countries in the Arab region which are currently experiencing challenges to autocracy. The new settlements will be shaped by historical traditions, the type of political elite, levels of economic development, the power and role of the armed forces, and external pressures from the international community, among many other factors. But preferences in the mass culture are also likely to play a role in any constitutional settlement, especially where these are subject to popular referendum, as in Tunisia. It is therefore important to determine whether the general public in Muslim-plurality nations favors the Turkish model of secular democracy, the Iranian model of religious autocracy, or another type of constitutional settlement located between these poles.

Regimes can be classified using a four-fold typology which distinguishes preferences for liberal democracy (on the horizontal axis) and preferences for secular states, defined here as those favoring high levels of religious pluralism and freedom, on the vertical axis. Comparison of Muslim-plurality societies suggest that they are governed today by diverse types of regimes, which can be illustrated by the contrasts among Mali (exemplifying a secular democracy), Chad (classified as a secular autocracy), and Tunisia (as a religious autocracy).

	Low << Liberal democracy >> High
Low << Religious pluralism >> High	Secular autocracy	Secular democracy
	Religious autocracy	Religious democracy

 

Public preferences for each type of regime

 

What type of regime do Muslims publics prefer? The World Values Survey 1999-2007 provides data in a wide variety of societies to examine the distribution of public opinion towards secularism and democracy.

 

Preferences for a secular state are measured by two items: "How strongly do you agree or disagree with each of the following statements?(i) Religious leaders should not influence how people vote in elections; (ii) Religious leaders should not influence government decisions."

 

Support for democratic principles is measured by the question: "I'm going to describe various types of political systems and ask what you think about each as a way of governing this country. For each one, would you say it is a very good, fairly good, fairly bad or very bad way of governing this country? (i) Having a democratic political system. (ii) Having a strong leader who does not have to bother with parliament and elections; (iii) Having experts, not government, make decisions according to what they think is best for the country; (iv) Having the army rule."

 

Figure 1: Public preferences for regimes

 

 

The results of the comparison in Figure 1 shows that the publics in Muslim-majority societies displayed diverse preferences; hence people living in some countries, such as Tanzania and Morocco, favored secular democracy, while others such as Albania and Indonesia proved slightly less supportive of democracy although equally secular, and still others, such as Algeria, favored religious autocracy. Overall, therefore, although some assume commonality, the contrasts among Muslim-plurality societies stand out.

Source: More details can be found in Pippa Norris. 2011. 'Muslim support for secular democracy'. www.pippanorris.com

Comments

[commodity tips]

Hi,
this one is great and is really a good post. I think it will help me a lot in the related stuff and is very much useful for me. Very well written I appreciate & must say good job.

[landscape design toronto]

I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well. In fact your creative writing abilities has inspired me to start my own Blog.

[landscape designer toronto]

Your blog is great visually, I mean people wont be bored. But others who can see past the videos and the layout wont be so impressed with your generic understanding of this.

[hoteles]

The one that created this post can be a genius and learns how to keep your readers connected..Thank you for sharing this with us. I uncovered it informative and interesting.

[canada goose]

Algeria, favored religious autocracy. Overall, therefore, although some assume commonality, the contrasts among Muslim-plurality societies stand out.

[commodity tips]

Many thanks for the exciting blog posting! I really enjoyed reading it, you are a brilliant writer. I actually added your blog to my favorites and will look forward for more updates. Great Job, Keep it up.

[best fake tans]

This content has a lot of great information that is apparently intended to make you think. There are excellent points made here and I agree on many. I like the way this content is written.

[hoteles]

Thanks for sharing excellent informations. I’m impressed by the details that you’ve on this web site. I will come back for more articles.

[flowers hong kong]

Thanks for sharing superb information. It looks really delicious I also want to try it once. I am impressed by the info that you have on this site. I will come back if it has some informations again.

[toronto landscape contractors]

All I can think to say is wow! I think your info is intriguing and fascinating. You have done a great job on this article.

[landscape companies toronto]

Internet is written with the capital letter in a sentence, by the way. And hundredths are written not with a point but with a comma. This is according to the standard. And actually everything is very good..!!

[jerseys cheap]

There are some interesting time point in this article, but I don't know if I see all of the center to the heart. There is some truth, but I will seize the opinion, until I looked at it further. Good article, thank you, we want to have more!

[y8]

y8
Very gorgeous... I like it !! Thanks you for this beautiful web...
I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this post. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well. In fact your creative writing abilities has inspired me to start my own blog now.

[London escort agencies]

Cherrygirls is a comprehensive listing of London Escort Agencies. For all your London Escort Agencies requirements look no further. Cherrygirls shows a great selection of London escort agency escorts.

[toronto landscaper]

The quality of this article surpasses many others I’ve read. You have a keen eye for detail and your research was solid on this subject.

[Duo escorts]

London's newest escort agency, offering blonde and busty escorts as well as brunette and latin babes. You can book our escorts for incall or outcall throughout London. Please call use or visit www.smslondonescorts.com for further details.

[female escorts]

London escorts and escorts in London. Find them all here. For the best in London escort call Viva escorts.

[訂花]

That's great. I think it is very goos for some comment and blog. This helps others on their work/blog.Thank you.

[Mayfair escorts]

Are you looking for incall or outcall escorts in Central London? Check out our Mayfair escorts who are just a phonecall away. Mayfair, Central London for all your escort needs.

[Red Lobster Deals Online]

For the good of all our brothers and sisters. I will try to share this article to my fellow friends to let them know the current updates.

[landscaping contractors toronto]

Hi! Do you use Twitter? I’d like to follow you if that would be okay. I’m undoubtedly enjoying your blog and look forward to new updates.

[Dumpster Rental Chicago]

I am very thankful to all your team for sharing such inspirational information. It really helpful for us. Thanks a lot! Dumpster Rental Chicago

[discount bedroom set]

Thanks for providing some food for thought with this post.

[訂花,訂花]

I truly liked this post, if I have your permission should i reproduce this particular post to my weblog and share it with other people too. Naturally I am going to give the original credits to you only.

[bywmbxgr]

doudoune moncler Ct13@E moncler Yf11%O http://www.doudounemonclerkaraknoir.com/ Ui5#N

[xnprlprl]

canada goose Aj2&A canada goose chilliwack Bc6%M http://www.gorookiesgo.com Jq5$T

[firv]

This is great! It really shows me where to expand my blog. I think that sometime in the future I might try to write a book to go along with my blog, but we will see.Good post with useful tips and ideas
Thanks so much for your comment. I am wating for this information. Join now to share

[John]

Thanks for spreading this article... this really is a beneficial data.
http://www.writingpearl.co.uk/essay-writing-service/

[ajzmwhtj]

http://www.goosejacketonline.eu Moreover, wrap dresses, along with printed shirts and tops, V-necks and straight skirts are ideal for such a structure..
No niff-naff but pure lines with few but elegant jewellery. canada goose parkas There is no need to create your own ghillie suit though since it would even take you months to properly create one.
A Russian scientist 聞Fersman" calculated that in the earth crust up to the depth of 1000 metres there are resources of 5 million tons. beats by dre store She was later cast in Black and White by director James Toback and garnered glowing praise from critics for her performance.
http://www.goosejacketonline.eu

[訂花,訂花]

I have been looking for a rare blog because I am tired of accessing almost the same topic discussed in a website. This blog is actually hitting what I want to expect. I am very glad that you are now providing the information where I am hunting for many days of surfing the net. Thanks for this post. You really hits the target