Trust in democracy

Over the weekend, I attended a conference in The Hague on the issue of an erosion of trust in European democracies, especially focused on the situation in the Netherlands. The meeting was organized by the Dutch Ministry of the Interior, the Council for Public Administration, and NOW, the Netherlands Council for Scientific Research.

Much of the discussion centered around the perceived disaffection with democracy, and concern about an erosion of trust in government and in democratic institutions, including parties and parliament. Both academics and politicians emphasized that the Netherlands was experiencing a crisis of consocationalism, where the core values of tolerance, accommodation, and consensus, a source of deep national pride, were under growing threat. Many speakers thought that changes in the news media had contributed towards any growth in public cynicism and intolerance, alongside the 'personalization' of politics and the weakness of parties.

But the empirical evidence supporting the idea that political trust and satisfaction with democracy has steadily eroded, whether in Europe or the Netherlands, is by no means clear-cut. The following illustrates trends in satisfaction with democracy across a dozen European nations, as monitored by the Eurobarometer surveys from the early-1970s. The comparison covers a range of older democracies, as well as a few younger cases (Spain, Portugal and Greece). It also includes regimes with power-concentrating (majoritarian) institutions (such as France and the UK), as well as others with power-sharing (consensus) structures (such as Belgium and the Netherlands).

The overall results suggest a pattern of trendless fluctuations, rather than steady secular erosion in satisfaction. Indeed many countries such as Ireland, the Netherlands and Denmark show rising satisfaction across the period, while other cases display peaks and troughs, suggesting volatility, especially among younger democracies. The contrasts in levels of satisfaction among countries are also apparent, notably persistently low satisfaction in Italy, especially in contrast with the Netherlands. But there is no evidence here that power-sharing democracies have consistently experienced falling public satisfaction – or that there are any steady trends across European democracies. Similar Eurobarometer trends comparing trust in institutions also show a pattern of trendless fluctuations more than steady decline.

Table 1: Satisfaction with democracy, EU12 1972-2007

Source: Eurobarometer

So why were so many speakers at the conference convinced that a 'crisis' of public trust was apparent in the Netherlands?

In part, the explanation rests on the recent political history of the country, suggesting an era of growing party instability and polarization (Mair 2008). New issue cleavages, notably immigration and the rise of a more multicultural society, have generated strains challenging the old party politics of consensus accommodation. Moreover these developments have been exacerbated by the Dutch electoral system, a national party list system with an exceptionally low threshold of votes for parties to enter electoral office.

Following the 1994 general election, the 'Purple' Coalition was formed among PvdA (Labour), D66 (progressive liberal) and VVD (conservative liberal). During this era, the government introduced legislation on abortion, euthanasia and gay marriage. The coalition parties lost their majority in the 2002 earthquake elections, due to the rise of List Pim Fortuyn, the new political party led by the flamboyant populist Pim Fortuyn, campaigning on an anti-immigration programme. The assassination of Fortuyn a week before polling day boosted his party's support; the LPF entered parliament with one sixth of the seats, while the PvdA (Labour) lost half its seats. A cabinet was formed by CDA, VVD and LPF, led by Prime Minister Jan Peter Balkenende, but after only 87 days in power, the coalition fell apart as a result of consecutive conflicts within the LPF and between LPF ministers.

In the ensuing elections in January 2003, the LPF dropped to only five percent of the seats in the Second Chamber. The left-wing Socialist Party (SP) became the fourth party of the Netherlands. The centre-right Balkenende II cabinet was formed by the Christian-Democratic CDA, the conservative-liberal VVD and the progressive-liberal D66. Against popular sentiment, the right-wing coalition initiated an ambitious programme of welfare state reforms, health care privatization, and stricter immigration policies. On June 1, 2005, the Dutch electorate voted in a referendum against the proposed European Constitution by a majority of 62%, three days after the French had also rejected the treaty.

In June 2006, D66 withdrew its support for the coalition, triggering its collapse, and the Balkenende III caretaker cabinet was formed by CDA and VVD. The ensuing general elections held on 22 November 2006 saw a landslide victory for the Socialist Party, which almost tripled in size and became the third largest party with 17% of the seats, while the moderate PvdA (Labour) lost a quarter of its seats. At the other end of the spectrum, LPF lost all its seats, while the new anti-immigrant PVV went from nothing to 6% of the seats, becoming the fifth biggest party. This polarisation of the Second Chamber, with an even distribution between left and right, made the cabinet formation negotiations very difficult. The talks eventually resulted in the formation of the Social-Christian fourth cabinet Balkenende, by the PvdA, the CDA and the Christian Union.

The result has been new challenges arising to the stability of Dutch coalition governments. A country which has long prided itself on a culture of liberal tolerance, founded on elite accommodation in a consociational democracy, finds itself under growing difficulty in meeting these ideals.

These are indeed important developments but it is not clear that these elite-level challenges are necessarily reflected in long-term shifts in public attitudes towards Dutch democratic institutions, nor that changes in the news media (such as personalization and commercialization) or in campaign communications (such as any growth in 'negative' messages) have played a major role in these events. New issue cleavages, and the role of the radical right in exploiting these developments, is certainly an important phenomenon, but this has affected majoritarian political systems (such as support for LePen's Front National in France) as well as consociational or power-sharing systems (as exemplified by support for the radical right parties in Austria and Belgium). It remains to be seen whether the polarization of Dutch party politics persists, deepens (under the current economic climate), or possibly reduces, if bread-and-butter concerns with economic management return to the top of the political agenda

Reference for further information:

Mark Bovens & Anchrit Wille. 2008. Deciphering the Dutch drop: ten explanations for decreasing political trust in The Netherlands, International Review of Administrative Sciences, 74: 283-305.

Peter Mair. 2008. 'Electoral Volatility and the Dutch Party System: A Comparative Perspective.' Acta Politica, 4 (2-3):235-253

Comments

[basketbamt]

Yes, really. And I have faced it. We can communicate on this theme.
basketbamt bb4arg48

[OWxARQzv]

OWxARQzv
[url=http://www.f5iuiG353s483vG9NOHM1S.com/]OWxARQzv[/url]
OWxARQzv http://www.f5iuiG353s483vG9NOHM1S.com/

[ルアーロッド]

Report of great approaches to discover more about watch well before you're left out. ルアーロッド http://www.daiwapolejp.com/ロッド-ルアーロッド-c-12_69.html

[chanel outlet]

.. ..

[Gucci Handbags]

Gstebuch GraphicsArea

[UtIsKUDL]

[url=http://www.V8DZ374K8h1rm9bX6ss5dT.com/]UtIsKUDL[/url]
UtIsKUDL http://www.V8DZ374K8h1rm9bX6ss5dT.com/
UtIsKUDL

[ティンバーランドブーツ]

セイコー腕時計 セイコー腕時計 http://www.watches2013jp.cc/ グッチアウトレット グッチアウトレット http://www.guccibagsjp.cc/ ゴルフ 女子 ゴルフ 女子 http://www.goruhujp.cc/ オークリー アウトレット オークリー アウトレット http://www.raybanjpsale.cc/ オークリー アウトレット オークリー アウトレット http://www.oakleyglassessale.cc/

[ルブタン スニーカー]

miumiu 靴 miumiu 靴 http://www.miumiu2013sale.cc/ セリーヌ ラゲージ セリーヌ ラゲージ http://www.onlinecelinesales.com/ トリーバーチ バッグ トリーバーチ バッグ http://www.toptoryburchs.com/ トリーバーチ バッグ トリーバーチ バッグ http://www.toryburchsfield.com/ http://www.2011.aglsustainability.com.au/images/sitemap.asp?1_shoes

[Bestpreis]

www.billiger.de

[Tria]

Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed browsing your blog posts.
surat keterangan magang kerja terlengkap|Makanan Khas Bandung yang Maknyus

[401k withdrawal calculator]

He was widely remembered not only as one of the greatest basketball players of the century, but as a kind, warmhearted man.

[vancouver web design]

Not the most interesting article that I read. Although if you want you can make a first order on the-term-papers.com and get a discount and we'll all be happy.

[arrankenlapew]

jKbdwvDfnf ugg pas cher hRzebgVeuj uggs pas cher kMempuKfrr Website yNxtdkQrdd http://uggs-pascherbottes.webnode.fr/#89341 bSbhkjZear michael kors handbags bKbbbjPmoa michael kors handbags on sale yEmnibSqdo michael kors discount nYholtGkvr http://michaelkorshandbagss.webeden.net/#91169 tSwumbMwdm louboutin pas cher yEwuavJcrs chaussure louboutin pas cher sYysgcGpih Read More Here yFsxnrAjwx http://chaussure-louboutinpascher.webnode.fr/#11552

[nrgvlqsd]

See that was not so hard!. ugg boots preisvergleich
ugg sandals sale ugg short boots ugg classic cardy leopard ugg boots Each Brighton handbag goes through 20 steps during its creation.
botte ugg cheap ugg boots sale ebay ugg www.soldesuggpascher.eu ugg jimmy choo

[Twidirmdriego]

fbnmy xzksl louboutin homme ivzwi vzpjqt Pippa Norris's Weblog: Trust in democracy hrkhozi http://www.frmabercromfitchmagasinn.info/ mzchhym hplna

[la roulette en ligne]

I will not blame the government for trying to prevent banks from raping consumers. It blows my mind that they are doing this in plain sight of us all. First they take 700 billion dollars out of our pockets because their dirty money making schemes failed (and nearly caused the collapse of the country), and now they’re taking more money out of our pockets to fatten their profits even more. We are being bent over and robbed and no one seems to care. The government and corporations both have their problems but at least the government has the best interest of the citizens and country in mind…at least to some extent. Corporations interest is profit at any cost, even if it means destroying american citizens and the country as a whole. They will bring america to its knees.

[insogueattito]

CogeOnentee steelers Nike jerseys
KileTimiMex patriots Nike jerseys
Haummomfowl steeler jersey nike
NarHonenribia cowboys Nike jerseys
Immubmada giants nike jersey

[no deposit casino online]

You’ve acquired quite amazing stuffs the following. I really like the actual concept with the web site and how well you prepared this content. It is a outstanding career I am going to keep coming back and appearance you out someday.

[foredi]

Thank u for sharing excellent information.I'm impressed by the details that you have on this web

[jogos de casino]

There are God designed roles that should be embraced if anyone is to experience "marital bliss." This couple makes you uncomfortable because they are *more* Christ-like in their view of marriage than you. Truth always makes truth-deniers uncomfortable.

[Commodity Trading Tips]

Yes you are best author of in this blog .Really good posting and informative .

[Share Tips,Free Share Tips]

" Thank you for your posting.
Seems like a nice blog. Your way of delivering post is nice"

[gokkasten spelen]

Thanks for making such a cool post which is really very well written, will be referring a lot of friends about this.Keep blogging.

[http://www.rushessay.org/essay-help]

You say this paper shows that I feel, I hope you have a better development.

[bestessays.com review]

We need to protect the jobs and natural resources that keep our local communities strong and healthy, public schools and critical services and we can’t afford more tax breaks that only benefit the wealthy.

[casino android]

This is a very good blog just full of useful information. thanks for sharing this post

[amurgeguimams]

Justin Bieber Supra,i7fl97, Jordan Retro Shoes,h4ae42, Justin Bieber Shoes,v5zp05, Justin Bieber Shoes,y7vb58,

[mdlslhtjxfhu]

The Myth Debunked: No one with a true comprehension of the Law of Attraction has ever claimed that if you just think a confident thought, a house with a million dollars on the dining room table and a Ferrari in the driveway will just drop out from the sky right in front of you.

http://transvaginalmeshlawsuit.designsbydel.com/women-wavers-monetary-benefit-with-transvaginal-mesh-lawsuits-2/


Some of the ointments for yeast infection treatments are used only at bedtime as they might leak out during the day. The QuickVue Strep Test" which costs significantly less than $4 per test in a pack of 25, can quickly help you determine if your child has a strep infection, which would demand a doctor's visit, from the common viral infection, which may not. How to make use of the link the IQ Protocol to OSHA requirements to improve your total regulatory compliance.

For most women embarrassment doesn`t end there, aside from the admission matter to having an itchy vagina, it really is them awkward moments, and all of us ask them to, is if the have to scratch the vagina happens when out socializing with friends.

[ieiymbxg]

The diamond industry pulls in with regards to USD 50 billion inside a year. This wealth is created as a result of exclusive tag that is certainly attached to most of these precious stones termed diamonds. While the simulated diamonds industry suits market that detects real diamonds a bit out of their particular reach, it also, as mentioned previously, helps reduce the actual conflict in Photography equipment nations, where wars will be funded by fulfilling the necessity for diamonds. A comparison involving simulated diamonds as opposed to real diamonds will in a very obvious manner mention how the clarity and benefit of a real diamond will not match that of your simulated diamond. But the top quality of simulated diamonds has improved a lot over the years making it quite difficult to indicate differences when contrasting synthetic diamonds or natural diamonds. But there are generally some key differences you could look out regarding.\r'),
http://buypandorajewellery.webeden.co.uk/ - pandora uk
You must always be put into for a small ring that has a flexible and clamping attach. The big kinds look very odd and get noticed in odd directions sometimes. You can receive these fake video from any necklaces shop or piercing shop which sells artificial items as well. Or you could use fake ear piercing rings on your own eyebrow, as these look great too. The problem lies in the belief that fake eyebrow piercings may look real, but it will depend on how properly it suits and fits your eyebrow. Do not go ahead for rings that are fitted with designs or shades, as it will result in people to pay out more attention within the piece of jewelry.\r'),
http://buypandorajewellery.webeden.co.uk/ - pandora jewellery
A diamond is all of which will remain the many precious stone that is known. Over the many years, a technique pertaining to systematic analysis of the value of a diamond has become developed, that considers the many factors which create a diamond valuable. The Four C''s - ''Clarity, Carat, Cut and Color'' decide the price of a diamond. There is some sort of grading system to judge each one of these characteristics of some sort of diamond. I will make clear the accepted diamond clarity evaluation system and offer a diamond clearness chart, that helps to make an objective evaluate of its quality. Read more in Diamond Grading Graph.\r'),
http://buypandorajewellery.webeden.co.uk/#3210 - pandora bracelet uk
A conflict diamond is any diamond that comes from such a conflict affected country the place that the profits from this industry head over to fund arms industry or military organizations. During these competitions, armed warriors clash for that command of the diamond mines because of the immense profitability. As it happens everywhere, the combating are not able to restrict to combatants and civilians tend to be killed during these kinds of campaigns.\r'),
http://buypandorajewellery.webeden.co.uk/#2243 - pandora shops uk
Diamonds are formed under tremendous warmth and pressure. These conditions exist 150 km in order to 200 km underneath the earth''s surface, where the temperatures are extremely high ranging by 900脗潞C to 1300脗潞C. For millions connected with years, carbon atoms deep in the earth''s upper mantle are already exposed to most of these extreme conditions. As a effect, these atoms incorporate their cubic molecular type and ultimately style diamond crystals. During volcanic eruptions, diamond crystals at some point make their solution to the earth''s exterior through pipes along with channels. These pipes or channels support the magma from this volcano, which rises combined with the diamonds and deposits them on top where they tend to be later found and mined. These are often known as the primary deposits of diamond. Kimberlite is the blue rock and the most common host of diamonds within the earliest volcanic water lines.\r'),
http://buypandorajewellery.webeden.co.uk/#2450 - cheapest pandora bracelets

http://buypandorajewellery.webeden.co.uk/

[Steel Stockholders Scotland]

Thanks speakers thought that changes in the news media had contributed towards any growth in public cynicism and intolerance, alongside the 'personalization' Steel Stockholders Scotland