The electoral politics of the Liberal-Conservative Coalition Government

Coalition politics is a familiar process in most European countries. There are no guarantees of the final results, as polling day can bring many unexpected outcomes, sometimes generating month-long negotiations requiring grand coalitions of parties drawn from across the political spectrum in order to cobble together a government. Nevertheless during the election campaign, European parties often signal their willingness to collaborate with potential coalition partners, and which parties are outside this process, providing voters with clues about the eventual outcome.

In the United Kingdom, however, the British government coalition joining the fate of the Liberal Democrat and Conservative parties, announced yesterday in the Rose Garden of No 10, seems to have been utterly serendipitous for all concerned, even to commentators, pundits and the party leaders involved at the heart of this process. The outcome, the first governing coalition in Britain since the end of World War II, and the first ever Conservative-Liberal Democratic coalition in history, was unexpected despite the long series of public opinion polls predicting a hung parliament. It was agreed by the party leaders only during the five days of negotiations following the election, after it became apparent that the Conservatives were the largest party at Westminster but without an overall parliamentary majority.

Why the surprise?

In terms of ideological and policy positions, for a decade the Liberal Democrats and the Labour party have always been closer; indeed in the 2001 and 2005 elections, the Comparative Manifesto Project estimated that the Liberal Democrat manifesto was more progressive and slightly to the left of the Labour party platform, especially on issues of taxation and proposed levels of social welfare spending. By contrast, although the Conservatives have moved closer to the center of the British political spectrum under the leadership of David Cameron, nevertheless they remained further to the right of their other main rivals. And on certain issues, notably Europe, the Liberal Democrats and the Conservatives remain miles apart.

But how are the parties placed by voters? Did the coalition, and the decision by Nick Clegg to join with the Conservatives rather than Labour, reflect the outcome that the British public wanted? During election night, Paddy Ashdown famously said that the people have spoken, but we still don't know what they have said. One problem was that the main exit polls, commissioned by all the major media organizations, failed to ask any questions beyond voting. So the coalition has generated a mountain of speculations offered by all sides but no systematic evidence. Those reading the tea-leaves often claimed that the British public 'wanted' a hung parliament but, in fact, this cannot be deduced from the outcome. Each citizen cast a particular vote in their specific constituency, but the final outcome was the collective result of millions of independent decisions.

One way we can throw light on this question is to turn to the 2010 British Election Study (BES) which has just been released. The BES data provides some revealing clues about what the electorate actually preferred. And in particular the results tell us something important about the second choice of Liberal Democrat voters. If the decision about entering a coalition with either Labour or the Conservatives were in the hands of Liberal Democrat voters, what would they have wanted?

The table below, drawn from the BES campaign panel survey among 1,355 respondents, reports how people voted on May 6^th and also reveals their second choice preference among those who voted but who really preferred another party. Among those in this group who cast a ballot for the Liberal Democrats, only 12% opted for the Conservative party as their second choice preference. By contrast, almost half the Liberal Democrat voters (48%) chose Labour as their second preference. Likewise, the Liberal Democrats were the 2^nd choice preference of four out of ten Labour voters.

In other words, it is not simply that the Labour and the Liberal Democrats parties are far closer in their manifesto policies and ideological values, but Liberal Democrat and Labour voters also recognized the close affinity in their willingness to switch votes. The Conservative party was in a far different position, where UKIP (to the right of the party) were their largest 2^nd choice party.

Thus the new coalition governing British politics has clearly shaken up the old pattern of British party politics. Whether the decision of the leaders will cause Liberal Democrat voters to move gradually closer towards the Conservatives in their electoral sympathies, or whether instead the Liberal Democratic party will eventually be punished by their supporters for entering this alliance, remains a fascinating question which only time will tell.

	How people voted on May 6th 2010
Among those who preferred another party	Conservative voter	Labour voter	Lib-Dem voter
Con 2nd choice	13	2	12
Lab 2nd choice	4	22	48
Lib-Dem 2nd choice	21	43	15
SNP 2nd choice	1	4	3
PC 2nd choice	0	2	1
UKIP 2nd choice	41	8	4
BNP 2nd choice	10	6	1
Green 2nd choice	2	9	11
Other 2nd choice	10	6	6
	100	100	100

Source: British Election Study 2010 Campaign Panel. F/w YouGov. N. 1,355

Comments

[Payday loan]

, http://www.viagraonlineie.com/ Sildenafil, qca, http://www.genericviagraonlineusa.com/ Viagra online, 15256, http://www.usamedichq.com/ Levitra, 8PPP, http://www.paydayloansonlinewww.com/ Payday loans, 8-))), http://www.viagraonlinewss.com/ Viagra online without prescription, 697, http://www.genericviagrabp.com/ Generic viagra online, ktjk, http://www.cheapviagraonlineusa.com/ Viagra, =O, http://www.levitraonlinemedss.com/ Levitra cialis viagra, :-DDD,

[Buy levitra from canada]

, http://www.cheapcialisws.com/ Cheap cialis, 42797, http://www.buycialissw.com/ Cialis, zsgwnj, http://www.cialisonlineusabiz.com/ Cialis canada, jzsa, http://www.buylevitrawww.com/ Buy levitra pills, zavm, http://www.genericviagrasl.com/ Cheap generic viagra, pzmnzs, http://www.buyviagrasr.com/ Buy viagra online, 973276, http://www.genericviagrasle.com/ Generic viagra, 683952, http://www.genericcialisusaonlines.com/ Cialis, 92632, http://www.viagraonlineshopusa.com/ Viagra samples, %-OOO,

[angela03]

The primary impact of the Electoral College is to give the citizen. wheel alignment

[hemorrhoids]

the parties note that the credibility of a plan on deficit reduction depends on its long-term deliverability.

[canada goose]

I really enjoy simply reading all of your weblogs. Simply wanted to inform you that you have people like me who appreciate your work. Definitely a great post. Hats off to you! The information that you have provided is very helpful.

[presentes de natal]

Your blog has such good information that always makes me think. We know that the election in the US now is ongoing and we need to vote for the right one that will serve the people.

[click here]

So we could acquire more time for you to sleep prior to the addition of the year or so of saving robustness.

[Tips by Femme Foodies]

Thanks I didnt give lots of consideration to leaving comments on site page articles and have placed comments even much less.

[LeadingQuest]

the type of government depends on the type of election result.

[dentista em casa]

Recently, I didnt give lots of consideration to leaving comments on site page articles and have placed comments even much less. Reading via your nice posting, will assist me to do so sometimes.

[Oliver]

I do not like the opinions specified in this weblog and I felt that you need to have done more research in advance.

[YanqingWei.com]

Thanks enjoy simply reading all of your weblogs. Simply wanted to inform you that you have people like me who appreciate your work.

[hemorrhoids]

Definitely a great post. Hats off to you! The information that you have provided is very helpful.

[WeBuyAnyCar]

The bag has been designed for the festive holiday season for the modern people.

[dentista em casa]

Liberals believe in government action to achieve equal opportunity and equality for all. It is the duty of the government to alleviate social ills and to protect.

[Chicago moving company]

I do not like exactly how you have jotted down a few of your individual viewpoints along with the realities yet I do like exactly how the blog site was written completely thank you.

[patriciar]

choosing a candidate for office in an organization by the vote of those enfranchised to cast a ballot ballot, means of voting for candidates for office. hemrid

[wicker furniture]

Thanks most dangerous institutions in American politics today. The primary impact of the Electoral College is to give the citizen.

[dentista em casa]

Your blog has such good information that always makes me think. We know that the election in the US now is ongoing and we need to vote for the right one that will serve the people.

[seguro de viagem]

Recently, I didnt give lots of consideration to leaving comments on site page articles and have placed comments even much less. Reading via your nice posting, will assist me to do so sometimes.

[GotoGreemyrib]

ScpZnx ugg boots sale kqwuid http://uggbootsukcheapugg.webeden.co.uk/ HcxRyi UGG Boots UK qiypmt http://uggbootsukcheapshopuk.webeden.co.uk/ GbkMnc ugg boots sale stjhzf http://uggbootssaleuk2013.webeden.co.uk/ BvpNxi Cheap UGG Boots Sale tqvulv http://uggbootssalesukuk.webeden.co.uk/ CuyEtx ugg boots uk gtxyby http://cheapuggbootssaleshop.webeden.co.uk/ XcwLwd Cheap UGG Boots Sale hkrkgi http://cheapuggbootssaleukshop.webeden.co.uk/ HedEub cheap ugg boots sale qtebkq http://cheapuggbootsuk2013.webeden.co.uk/ HfwTcw UGG Boots Sale tacfot http://cheapuggbootsuksaleuk.webeden.co.uk/

[Whellamen]

bwmhe woedg louis vuitton purses bffeg wzgwii Pippa Norris's Weblog: The electoral politics of the Liberal-Conservative Coalition Government tuyblqd http://loubutinnshoesxoutletstores.webeden.net/ tzxthzi iznzv

[dissertation]

So the coalition has generated a mountain of speculations offered by all sides but no systematic evidence.

[sexshops]

Your blog has such good information that always makes me think. We know that the election in the US now is ongoing and we need to vote for the right one that will serve the people.

[cheereeNeep]

SuvQbd ugg boots sale leevbv http://uggbootsukcheapugg.webeden.co.uk/ FijGfu UGG Boots Sale qgvuxl http://uggbootsukcheapshopuk.webeden.co.uk/ LhhKog cheap ugg boots sale vgmkmm http://uggbootssaleuk2013.webeden.co.uk/ LylDki UGG Boots UK tsgwor http://uggbootssalesukuk.webeden.co.uk/ BofDms ugg boots uk emwuog http://cheapuggbootssaleshop.webeden.co.uk/ LfwKxl Cheap UGG Boots Sale locfvv http://cheapuggbootssaleukshop.webeden.co.uk/ JznChj cheap ugg boots gfljny http://cheapuggbootsuk2013.webeden.co.uk/ HxvNqp UGG Boots Sale xqkisz http://cheapuggbootsuksaleuk.webeden.co.uk/

[Pipjet]

Arabian Sinbad is a great package that helps learn Arabic via Cartoons. Just watch and learn. It is great for children and suitable for all

[TyncinennaGat]

Pippa Norris's Weblog: The electoral politics of the Liberal-Conservative Coalition Government jvdert pifhwhl ytwfzg north face paris rfmikap qvtwvcbb doudoune moncler pas cher fadqfdo plvuv

[How to Make Money with a Blog]

The parties agree that a plan for deficit reduction should be set out in an emergency budget within 50 days of the signing of any agreement; the parties note that the credibility of a plan on deficit reduction depends on its long-term deliverability, not just the depth of immediate cuts. New forecasts of growth and borrowing should be made by an independent Office for Budget Responsibility for this emergency budget.

[neonatal nurse]

Recently, I didnt give lots of consideration to leaving comments on site page articles and have placed comments even much less. Reading via your nice posting, will assist me to do so sometimes.

[roulette online]

Hats off to you! The information that you have provided is very helpful.